28
Nov
07

Movie Review: Zeitgeist - The Movie

Title: Zeitgeist - The Movie
Release: 2007
Genre: Documentary
Run Time: 116 Minutes
Author: Peter Joseph
Rating: 68%
URL: http://www.zeitgeistmovie.com/ (watch online)

After an excessively long introduction, Zeitgeist launches into a dissection of religion (titled “The Greatest Story Ever Told”), and by religion the film-makers mean Christianity. A brief summary of astrology gives way to a comparison of earlier Middle-Eastern mythologies to the mythology which predated all of them. Indeed there are many coincidences to between the Egyptian Sun God Horus and the central figures of later faiths:

  • Horus was born December 25th to the virgin Isis
  • He was adorned by three “kings” who followed an eastern star
  • He was deemed a prodigy at 12 and was baptized at the Age of 30
  • He traveled with 12 disciples and traveled around performing miracles like healing the sick and walking on water
  • His alternate names included “Lamb of God”, “The truth, the light”
  • He was betrayed, crucified, buried from the dead and rose three days later

Anyone who paid attention during Sunday school or at least made an effort to read a bible (a group encompassing fewer Christians that one would think) should be a bit uneasy, as the Story of Jesus Christ is nearly identical - only the names differ. Strangely (or perhaps not) the same general sequence of events can be found many other mythologies across the world. The film then attempts to link common attributes of these stories to astrological symbolism and does a fairly convincing job of it.

None of this information (or at least the discussion of its legitimacy) should be new to armchair theologians, but it was not initially clear why Christianity was singled out above all others for astrological plagiarism - it was not the first, last or worst offender among the emerging faiths. Eventually, the answer is provided - the Romans apparently invented the myth of Jesus Christ solely to exercise social and economic control over Europe. Never mind Karl Marx’s Opiate of the Masses attack - the Zeitgeist narrator directly refers to Christianity and similar faiths as “the fraud of the age”. Them be Fightin’ words.

Alas, Zeitgeist is a film about conspiracy theories - an emphatic diatribe of how small groups of shadowy figures conspire to control the masses.

Bush’s Brawn

The second part of the movie, titled “All the World’s a Stage”, attempts to prove that the US government plotted the 9/11 attacks in New York and contracted the dirty work to international resources. Provided evidence includes a mixture of the apparent “TV clips of witnesses describing a second explosion”, the questionable “government efforts to hide any conclusive evidence of a Boeing 757 hitting the Pentagon” and the perplexing “the demolition-like accuracy with which the buildings collapsed”. Again, the viewer is presented with a series of facts that are true or at least believable, some arousing anecdotes and a consequential induction that implicates shadowy powers.

If film-maker Peter Joseph can be credited for one thing, it’s flawlessly utilizing Dale Carnegie’s yes-yes technique to influence the viewer. Like any good conspiracy theorist, he starts with information that is true (yes #1), follows with information that is apparent enough to make the viewer question previous dogma (yes #2) and inserts his interpretation of what is driving those occurrences (in this case, that the US government intentionally detonated the twin towers). One major distinction between a conspiracy theory and a valid explanation is that conspiracy theories rarely work inversely as deduction. As a Math Professor of mine loved to recite, proving all poodles are dogs does not prove all dogs are poodles.

Hand in my Pocket

The third section is called “Don’t Mind The Men Behind The Curtain” and deals with disproportionate influence exercised by early banking tycoons like JP Morgan and John D Rockefeller. The stock market crash of 1929 is alleged to have been deliberately engineered by the “international bankers” to allow a large-scale cash grab and easy purchase of failed rivals. The 1933 American gold seizure, establishment of the US Federal Reserve and the major world wars of the 20th century are also attributed to the objectives of the international bankers, who stood to gain from the interest on loans made to both the state and consumers. These bankers are never clearly defined after the first generation of financial barons. More alarmingly, the Federal Income Tax is declared unconstitutional - a declaration backed by a pair of former IRS agents who testify to avoiding tax payment for years without penalty. Perhaps they could share what they know with Wesley Snipes.

Zeitgeist closes, strangely, with a motivational speech about unity and how the human race should unshackle themselves from the social structures imposed by a diabolical few. It did provide levity for an otherwise bleak film, but nonetheless sounded kitschy.

Worth a Tin-Foil Hat?

Is Zeitgeist worth the watch? Probably, as you can watch it for free via the URL provided above. The movie also provides an opportunity to test your critical thinking - the real enjoyment in indulging conspiracy theories is not self-congratulation for being skeptical, but being able to explain precisely where they fail.

Conversely, you may find yourself occasionally saying “wait a minute!” and questioning what you thought you knew. Sadly, conspiracy theories are one of the few remaining outlets for some good old-fashioned, politically-incorrect debate, and one area Zeitgest excels at is stimulating debate. Invite a friend or two over and have fun.


Bookmark this article: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • e-mail
  • Digg
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Propeller
  • Facebook
  • Live

29 Responses to “Movie Review: Zeitgeist - The Movie”


  1. 1 Jack Dec 2nd, 2007 at 8:12 pm
    Good one — you amaze me.

    You’re up in the AM.

  2. 2 Anna Keightley Dec 4th, 2007 at 10:10 am
    Excellent review and explanation, Cynapse. Now where would Gibbon’s “Rise and Fall of the Roman Empire” fit into this picture. You’d have to think about the Roman Empire engineering its own demise. Possible? Anything is.
  3. 3 Brandon Williams Dec 8th, 2007 at 3:14 am
    I am a strong follower of Christ, consider myself a Christian and really enjoyed the movie. Though I am a Christian I have 2 points of views about this movie and the reviews I have been reading. One (and I could guess why) the defenders of the Christian faith defense was not presented and taken out of context. This is already a long comment so I won’t go into detail. Two, though I do not agree with all of his points of views I think when ever some one believes in a conspiracy there just shrugged off but remember many of the greatest horrors of history was just conspiracy theories. Detailed sources would be nice. Thanks for listening.
  4. 4 Cynapse Dec 8th, 2007 at 9:12 am
    Brandon:

    The film producers have a list of sources for each section of the movie:

    http://www.zeitgeistmovie.com/sources.htm

  5. 5 Emilia Liz Dec 11th, 2007 at 11:13 pm
    If I can find a babysitter for my daughter, I might just watch this movie and review it for my church bulletin. So thank you for bringing it to my attention.
  6. 6 Me Dec 28th, 2007 at 7:53 am
    If you’re trying to say Christianity didn’t steal most of their stuff from pagan religions you fail miserably, since you failed to point out christmas has NOTHING to do with Jesus, or his birth.
  7. 7 Sir Dec 28th, 2007 at 11:57 am
    How can essential objective information be called a conspiracy except in an attempt to dismiss it completely? If only there was more objective info to support religion, there wouldn’t be any questioning it to begin with!
  8. 8 mi yu Jan 1st, 2008 at 5:41 pm
    As for the religion thing, I think it’s much more likely that Jesus was a real person (why would the Romans invent somebody that would encourage society to challenge war/imperialism?) but that many of the traditions and rituals were fused with already existing customs.
  9. 9 Not important Jan 8th, 2008 at 11:05 pm
    The whole point of the movie to not to make you believe what they are telling you because it is simply what they believe, that would be completely against what they are saying. What they want you to do is think about, RESEARCH FOR YOURSELF!, and believe what you want. Any of you can research a topic, any topic, and then make the decision for yourself after you see it with your own eyes. Unfortunately, for most of you, their plan worked, it made all of you think twice, even for a second.
  10. 10 Dan Jan 8th, 2008 at 11:53 pm
    I think the first section of the movie has a lot of questionable parts. Like the astronomy part seems like with the randomness of the astrology you can relate it to almost anything. But the ages part was pretty interesting how were going through monthly, seasonly, and a very long age all at once. The 2nd and 3rd section are awesome and totally hit key factors that make people believe 911 was an inside job. I do believe it was an inside job. The 3rd section is nuts too and basically sets the stage for the ideas of New World Order. This stuff is very interested id suggest watching “Loose Change” and reading the book “Behold a Pale Horse’ by William Cooper. I am a few chapters in and already its blowing my mind.
  11. 11 Terry Jan 9th, 2008 at 1:05 pm
    As for myself, after being around for 50 years the information I received over time about the universe, earth, dinosaurs, man, time, religion, power, control, destiny, had conceptual gaps, or inconclusive information. My dad always told us if you new only half of what is really going on it would scare you to death.
    Although I agree it is easier to believe in a simplified version of reality, or to be in a bias overtone toward it, I believe the movie has done a great justice in moving us forward to what our world needs which is critical thinking, and a promotion of peace. If any Christians deny this it proves the control theory in part one.
    Thou shall not kill! The no.1 point of the movie!

    Attack on Iraq:
    A man comes to your door and convinces you to
    give your life savings to a new annuity policy
    and you loose it all to junk bonds- forfeiting your
    children’s future.

    Attack on Iran:
    Now the man comes back and wants what you have
    left and inslave your grandchildren.

    Reach the senses of the people, restore hope.

    TR

  12. 12 Thinkaboutit Jan 12th, 2008 at 5:46 pm
    The conversation between Nicholas Rockafeller and Aaron Roseau outlined three main points:

    Invasion of Iraq (already happened)
    Invasion of Iran (already happened)
    Removal of Chavez from Venezuela..

    There are some recent issues going on regarding the prisoner/hostage-exchange between the Farcs and the Columbian government. Chavez was initially playing the role of mediator, but was removed from this position by Uribe (columbian pres), because he apprently shows too much compassion towards the Farcs.

    The Farcs are deemed terrorist groups by the US and Columbian government, but Chevez believes that they are a politically legitimate group.

    If this goes the way that was predicted, I would be rather surprised.

  13. 13 j0shi Jan 13th, 2008 at 12:50 pm
    Regarding the banker tycoons influence, I thinnk they wont be able to so far ahead as to have `one world` but they sure are going to have everyone debted.. :)

    Ever taken a bank loan and tried to pay it back before time? The bank levies penalty like charges because you are paying back early.

  14. 14 You and God Jan 17th, 2008 at 11:15 pm
    The movie is about YOU and what you deserve, your real importance and beauty, how strong and perfect we are and how we don’t know to enjoy all the nature, life around us. The conversation between an human being and God should be private, personal, individual, away from any intrusion, advice or orientation. Every single person has the right to connect with god by it’s own way.
  15. 15 Read this Jan 19th, 2008 at 10:20 pm
  16. 16 Chris Jan 24th, 2008 at 5:51 pm
    The purpose of this movie is not to make you believe what they are telling you. The purpose of it is to make you think for yourself. It is meant to spark an interest in what is going on in the society that we live in.
  17. 17 Nick Jan 28th, 2008 at 3:31 pm
    It’s really hard to find any info on the movie Zeitgeist other than it’s own website. However, all this review does is briefly outline the material, and passes it off. What I can’t understand is why people who get excited when the news tells them anything they haven’t heard before, but when they come across something like the movie Zeitgeist, which is full of very convincing material, and pass it off as a conspiracy and leisurely discuss it with their friends as if the topic was literature or dog breeding. The movie obviously designed to make one “mad.” It wants to stir up your emotions. You should feel very uncomfortable after watching this film, because although the film may not be completely factual, the possibility of truth should make you feel like complete shit. But who wants that? Discomfort in our own American living rooms?! No no no, the general public is much happier learning about the latest terrorists plots being foiled. They are much happier to discuss Zeitgeist with their friends, tossing the ideas back and forth like a hot potato, until its no longer hot. Perhaps we shouldn’t believe Zeitgeist, because if we do, we’d only be hypocrits right? However, I think that we need to take things a little more seriously.
  18. 18 Cynapse Feb 7th, 2008 at 1:02 am
  19. 19 Sir Feb 19th, 2008 at 12:58 pm
    Faith in “Exterior Power Sources”, relieves the mind of the burdens to acheiving more self-efficacy, which (self-efficacy) is the greatest enemy of falsehoods. The very things that the self has the most control over. The action of questioning everything is the first step of self-efficacy. Accept nothing into your belief system unless you fully understand the impact it has on your life and how it either makes you more or less aware. Believing can be most decieving! We must become our own best asset, and those whom have the greatest fears are those who adopt ‘ideas of truth based on beliefs’ as greater than honesty. Those that opt for faith, stop questioning and learning anything BEYOND what ‘that faith’ requires of itself to exist. Others will opt for Conscious Growth through HONESTY and questioning everything. It is time for man to take the next step, and rid himself of the ignorance that allows for the destuction of honest communication and critical thinking. We are on the edge of a new paradigm where faiths can be slain as the “darkness” and “ignorance pervaders” they in fact are! We must make our choice or continue to be fragmented and lose everything… the real End is near… which way will we choose…. life or death?
  20. 20 Eddy Feb 23rd, 2008 at 10:28 am
    Id just like 2 say sum parts of the movie feall very real like jesus being based on an older religion the romans making it in a new religon 2 controle peple very unlikely.but i do think that sum of it is true the calapse of building 7 on 9/11 never explaned by any degree by the goverment.I think the bank thing is definatley true basicaly a bank taking 35% of all amercans money and them not even being aware of it is frighting and all thay have 2 do is print money thats not worth any thing!But sum of it gets fare fetched.
    MAKE SURE YOU WATCH IT AND TELL YOUR FRIENDS TO!
    you can watch it at http://www.zeitgeistmovie.com/
  21. 21 No Name Feb 27th, 2008 at 10:13 pm
    Some of you people are incredible. Are you so blind that you can’t see what’s in front of you? The Zeitgeist movie doesn’t bring anything new…we all new all these fact for years now. You just need to open your eyes for one minute. This is no conspiracy,it’s the reality. And the sad fact is I do exactly the same thing. I preffer to ignore it and live on with my short,peaceful live. Hopefully someone will have the guts to stand up one day and say “Enough…”.
  22. 22 John Feb 28th, 2008 at 3:31 am
    i agree with a lot of u people…but its true most these things are real…tha northern american union with canada and mexico is real…go to youtube and search ron paul…they’ve actually asked him questions on debates…he knows about tha federal reserve…tha government keeps us dumb and doesn’t talk about tha evil they do so we don’t ask questions…time to wake up cus if not we’ll be nothing more then numbers in a database with a chip implanted in our bodies
  23. 23 Damian Mar 3rd, 2008 at 3:05 am
    Everyone needs to watch this and form their own opinions, religious or not. Research the claims yourself and prove them wrong. It would appear that this film has been made to inform, not to profit. If there is no truth to the majority of the film’s content why go to such an extent to promote it and have it screened in so many locations around the world simultaneously? Is the producer an eccentric millionaire with a hidden agenda? I don’t think so.
    The truth hurts, especially those with blind faith.
  24. 24 Next time Apr 6th, 2008 at 7:50 pm
    HA -HA -HA. Somebody gave this ling so I read this “…..The reason we celebrate December 25th is because a couple of centuries after the birth of Christ the church set that date deliberately to replace the Winter solstice celebrations, so of course there is a parallel to the winter solstice, but not for the reasons implied in the film…….”Then why they didn’t move it more precisely on 22 DEC And why exactly the chirch will do THAT?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!? Waw, people you are increidible!!!! To REJECT the truth when is INFRONT of YOU !!!!!!! Do you know how OSTRICH behaves when it sees some danger ?!?! You are behaving absolutely the same WAY!!! DING DING DING WAKE UP?!?!?! Or maybe JF Cenedy is still alive, or 50 000 000 people didn’t die during WWII !??! For HUMAN SAKE - THINK !!!
  25. 25 WOW May 8th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
    Christians are funny :P
  1. 1 Jack’s Newswatch Pingback on Dec 3rd, 2007 at 8:49 am
  2. 2 Movie Review: Zeitgeist - The Movie Pingback on Dec 3rd, 2007 at 10:04 pm
  3. 3 Cynics Unlimited » Movie Review: Loose Change - Final Cut Pingback on Feb 7th, 2008 at 1:00 am
  4. 4 Are you a thinkin' man? - Nebraska Fish and Game Association Pingback on Apr 15th, 2008 at 4:46 pm

Leave a Reply




Further Research